This is almost a perfect film.
Because it’s better than perfect.
Like Napoleon Dynamite, what should have been a larf was generally a sobfest for me throughout.
If you’re having problems in life, you need to see this movie.
Hollywood is so denigrated these days because the vast majority of popular cinema is utter shite.
From the very beginning, Pumpkin is different.
We should thank American Zoetrope.
And for that we have to thank Francis Ford Coppola and George Lucas.
Do you even know what a zoetrope is?
Well, I do.
And they did.
And it was le mot juste.
A zoetrope is special.
Let’s call it retarded cinema.
A more pure form. Slowed down.
Pumpkin grossed $308,552 at the box office.
No, I didn’t forget a comma and an additional three digits.
But the Bureau of Labor Statistics has no way of predicting the sort of inflation Pumpkin will experience in the annals of cinema history.
For any who have ever doubted Christina Ricci: this is her masterpiece.
As lead actress and coproducer, she gives a performance which goes deeper than even the esteemed Thora Birch in Ghost World.
Yes, this is that sort of film.
I have overused it of late.
But there is no other word. Pumpkin and Ghost World and Napoleon Dynamite are not second-class films to such as I fidanzati. No. They are equals with Ermanno Olmi’s masterpiece.
But don’t get confused.
Pumpkin goes in a direction completely “other” than any film I’ve ever seen.
Sure…it starts out tongue-in-cheek.
It is perhaps a dystopia which is best summed up by the saccharine mise-en-scène of The Truman Show. But where The Truman Show fails (and that is in many places), Pumpkin succeeds at telling a timeless story.
The story is the cast.
[Thank you Marshall McLuhan.]
Ricci is a thespian goddess here. Real skill. Real goddamn skill!
But neck-and-neck is Hank Harris.
I can’t nail it.
It’s something I saw long ago.
At my college orientation.
A bit of Sam Shepard and some other playwrights.
Sure. It is Steinbeck. Of Mice and Men.
But it’s more.
Sweeter. More optimistic. More frothing with disgust.
Frozen yogurt and 1400 on the SAT.
Harry Lennix is indispensable to the story. [start counting]
He is the angry poet. Not a college professor. And this is not a class.
This is a poetry workshop, motherfucker!
Even Julio Oscar Mechoso is indispensable in his short role as Dr. Frederico Cruz. [where we at?]
But let’s talk about some buttresses.
Melissa McCarthy is indispensable (truly) as Julie.
It’s not an easy role.
And yet, she’s not as bad off as Pumpkin.
Is it Christina Ricci with her jack-o’-lantern-perfect bob–her Chantal Goya -meets- David Bowie Low surf perm? That one little curl…so perfect…all the way ’round?
It’s Hank Harris.
He’s Pumpkin. Napoleon. Lothario.
But Sam Ball is especially indispensable here. [Ugh…]
He is Ken (actually Kent) to Ricci’s Barbie.
Spitting image of Ryan Reynolds.
Or Whitney Houston…
This cast brings it together.
Bringing it all back home are directors Anthony Abrams and Adam Larson Broder (neither of whom have a Wikipedia page).
BLOODY HELL, HOLLYWOOD! HOW COULD YOU CHURN OUT SO MANY FILMS AND NOT SEE THE BRILLIANCE OF THESE TWO BLOKES!?!?!?!?!
But in the end it’s just Ricci and Hank Harris.
The brilliance of a duo.
A truly timeless film.
I’m inclined to agree with many (including Dr. Steve Pieczenik) that Adam Lanza did not exist.
But Pumpkin Romanoff (a nod to Michael Romanoff, the storied Lithuanian restaurateur of 1940s/50s Hollywood?) most certainly did exist. For me. Tonight. When I needed him most.
This is immortality.
This looks like a good film! What a pity I’ve never heard of it….I have seen Christina Ricci in Prozac Nation and thought she did an okay job. You made it sound that she was phenomenal here. I think I will check it out!
Napoleon Dynamite made me laugh throughout, but it seems sad because the characters are so awkward with one another.
Thank you so much, Isabel 🙂 –Paul
That’s a huge compliment for you to place Christina Ricci above Thora Birch. I remember watching Ghost World with you. That movie was awesome. My favorite person was the old man on the bench, “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”
Thora is still my favorite, but Ricci does a great job here. I really never realized how great an actress she is until this film. –Paul